Chapter 5

Since my phone had been broken, I had lost contact with Caleb. I never expected him to still remember me. Every year on Evelyn’s birthday, I had been there—either cooking, serving tea, or making sure everything was perfect. I had been so consumed with her celebrations that I had forgotten my own birthday. The only time I had ever celebrated it was when my grandmother was alive. She had cooked me a simple bowl of longevity noodles. That was it. And now, even in death, I was here again. Watching. "Big Sis died in the fire, and it’s so tragic that she’s no longer with us. But today is Evelyn’s birthday, so let’s not dwell on sad things." Evelyn’s mother had tears in her eyes. Evelyn, ever the doting daughter, handed her a handkerchief, her expression sorrowful. I stared at them in disbelief. I had never seen that woman cry. She was always smiling, always cheerful. So why hadn't she shed a single tear when I actually died? Not even a pretense of mourning. "Sis always attended my birthday parties, but this year… something unexpected happened." The mother-daughter duo exchanged sorrowful glances, taking turns dabbing at their tears. It was picture-perfect grief. A textbook display of the deep mother-daughter bond they shared. I had never experienced it. Maybe I had been too dull. Maybe I had never learned how to please my parents like Evelyn did. Maybe that’s why they never loved me. Maybe it was because I didn’t know how to cry. Because if I had, maybe they would have paid attention to me. "The fire was too big," my father sighed heavily. "We could only save Evelyn. Every night at midnight, I wake up, haunted by the image of Big Sis begging us for help. I’m sorry, Big Sis." I drifted toward him, my cold, dead gaze locking onto his face. He was the one who slept the most soundly in that house. The one whose lies were always so smooth. If he had truly loved his beloved daughter, maybe he would have been heartbroken to know she was a murderer. But he didn’t care. He just didn’t want people whispering about it. Caleb wore a forced smile as he listened, pretending to be saddened by my death while also comforting my so-called grieving family. I clenched my fists, but my fingers simply passed through my dress like mist. A waiter rolled out a towering three-tiered cake, and the mood instantly shifted. Evelyn was radiant, standing in the center of her admirers. Beautiful. Elegant. Graceful. She basked in their praise like it was oxygen, her lips curling in satisfaction. I had seen this scene too many times before. From childhood to adulthood, she had always craved admiration. Always loved being flattered. I had learned early on that if I wanted to avoid a beating, all I had to do was praise her in front of my parents. They would get so distracted with their perfect daughter that they’d forget about me completely. Evelyn took the first slice of cake and held out the second piece to Caleb. But before he could take it, he turned to her with an unreadable expression. "This one should go to your sister." The room stilled for a fraction of a second. Evelyn’s hand tightened around the cake server. Her perfect smile wavered. Then, in an instant, it was gone. "I’ll give you this first slice instead," she said sweetly, pressing the fork into his hands. She had always liked being first. And now, she had decided he belonged to her, too. As guests enjoyed their cake, her friends continued to fawn over her. "Evelyn, if it weren’t for you, I’d never have gotten to eat at such an expensive restaurant." "Evelyn, your family is so rich. Your parents and sister spoil you so much! This birthday party is amazing! And your boyfriend is so handsome!" Evelyn smiled, her tone light. "Yes, my sister was always good to me. Whatever I wanted, she gave it to me." But her eyes gleamed with something else. Mockery. Yes. Whatever you wanted, I gave it to you. You even took my life. The room’s atmosphere shattered when the doors swung open. A police officer strode inside, his uniform crisp, his badge gleaming. "Evelyn Brooks," he announced, his voice steady, "you are under investigation for murder. Please come with us." The party froze. A collective gasp swept through the crowd. "Murder? That’s impossible!" "She’s so sweet! She would never hurt anyone!" "You never really know someone, do you?" The whispers buzzed like angry wasps. Evelyn’s mother clutched the officer’s arm, her voice frantic. "This has to be a mistake! My daughter is so kind—how could she possibly kill someone?" The officer remained calm. "I understand your concern, ma’am. But guilt or innocence will be determined by the law." For the first time that night, Evelyn looked truly afraid. She turned desperately to Caleb. "Caleb… do you believe me?" He didn’t answer. His lips parted slightly, but no words came. He simply stood there, his expression unreadable. When Evelyn was led out of the banquet hall in handcuffs, the party collapsed in on itself. Guests mumbled hurried excuses and vanished. Evelyn’s once-proud mother sagged, her face ashen, her fingers trembling. Her father—once an unshakable man—looked like he had aged ten years in mere minutes. As I watched them, I wondered— What would happen next? Would they fight to save her? Would they continue pretending? Or would the truth finally destroy them? Either way, I would be watching. _________