English
English English
Tiếng Việt Vietnamese
แบบไทย Thai

Chapter 4

Words : 0 Updated : Nov 17th, 2026
Mark promised to give me another birthday dinner. He chose Saturday, one week after the first one. He made a reservation at the Italian restaurant where we had celebrated our tenth anniversary. For six days, the reservation sat on our shared calendar beneath my name. On Friday night, it disappeared. I found Mark in the kitchen comparing brunch recipes on his tablet. Becca sat at the counter with Lily, sorting through baby-name cards. "What happened to dinner tomorrow?" I asked. Mark did not look up immediately. "Lily wants to take Becca out to celebrate the pregnancy." Lily placed one hand on her stomach. She was not showing yet, but the gesture had already become natural. "It's the only night Jason has off," she said. "We can do yours later." I looked at Mark. "Later when?" He set down the tablet. "Does it matter? We'll find another evening." "You said that last week." "And a lot has happened since then." The name cards made a soft clicking sound as Becca gathered them into a pile. "Mark, we can reschedule," she said. "I don't want to cause trouble." She said it while keeping one hand over the restaurant confirmation on Lily's phone. "You're not causing anything," Mark told her. I stood across from my husband in the kitchen I had renovated, beside flowers I had bought after no one brought any home for my birthday. "How many times does my fiftieth birthday get postponed before we admit no one plans to celebrate it?" Mark's expression changed from impatience to embarrassment. He glanced toward Lily. "You're fifty, Evelyn. Not five." No one spoke. The refrigerator hummed behind me. I thought of the half-covered banner and the sugar house standing in the center of my cake. "You're right," I said. Mark relaxed as if I had apologized. The next evening, everyone dressed for dinner. Becca wore my pearl earrings. Mark had found them in our bedroom and offered them to her because they matched her dress. She thanked me after they were already fastened. Ben arrived early with a bottle of sparkling cider for Lily. He kissed my cheek, then asked whether I had made the cinnamon bread Becca used to bake when they were children. "Tomorrow," Mark answered for me. "We're having a proper welcome-home brunch." I looked at him. "We are?" "I thought I mentioned it." He had invited twelve people. The grocery list waited on the counter. Eggs, fruit, bacon, cinnamon bread, and the coffee Becca preferred. Each item had a small box beside it. Beside the list sat the recipe card I had written for Lily when she moved into her first apartment. Mark had crossed out my measurements and replaced them with Becca's instructions from memory. More cinnamon. Less milk. Cut the crusts thinner. Even the breakfast I was expected to cook had been revised until it belonged to someone else. Mark handed me the list. "You should stay tonight and get a head start. Becca hasn't had a real family breakfast in years." Becca touched his arm. "Evelyn should come with us." For one second, her offer sounded sincere. Then she looked at the clock. "But the reservation is in twenty minutes." "It's fine," I said. There were those two words again. Ben carried the cider to the car. Becca went upstairs for her coat. Mark checked the restaurant address while Lily remained near the bottom of the stairs. "Dad," she said quietly. "Is Evelyn still upset? She looked hurt at the appointment too." I stopped above them, hidden by the turn in the staircase. Mark slipped his phone into his pocket. "Lily, she won't leave. You and Ben are her whole life." His voice softened. "She has too much invested in this family." For sixteen years, Mark had watched me choose the children over myself. He had mistaken every sacrifice for evidence that I had nowhere else to go. He did not believe I stayed because I loved them. He believed I stayed because there was nothing left of me outside this house. I walked upstairs and pulled a suitcase from the closet. I packed the red dress first. Then I added enough clothes for several weeks, my passport, medication, and the jewelry my mother had left me. From the bottom drawer of my nightstand, I took the box of cards Lily and Ben had given me over the years. Lily's card lay on top. Thank you for being the mother who stayed. I placed it inside my purse. Then I went to the studio. Becca's clothes hung from the back of my chair. Her cosmetics covered my paint table. My brushes remained sealed inside the cardboard box. I pulled the white sheet from my self-portrait. The woman in the red dress still had no eyes. I lifted the canvas from the wall and packed my paints. Everything else could stay. Downstairs, I gathered the sixteen family albums from the living-room shelves. I arranged them across the dining table, each opened to a photograph I had taken. Christmas mornings. Birthdays. Graduations. Family vacations. Mark, Lily, and Ben appeared in every one. I did not. On top, I placed the photograph from my fiftieth birthday. Mark stood beside Becca with one hand around her waist. Lily and Ben stood between them. They looked like a family that had finally become complete. On the back, I wrote: Sixteen years of family photographs. Find one where any of you remembered to ask me to step into the frame. I placed my camera on top of the photograph. Then I carried my suitcase and self-portrait outside. Nora answered my call on the first ring. "Can I stay with you tonight?" She heard something in my voice and didn't ask for an explanation. "I'm coming." Twenty minutes later, my suitcase was in her trunk and my unfinished portrait lay across the back seat. As we turned out of the neighborhood, my phone received a voice message from Mark. His tone was relaxed. "We'll be home in forty minutes. Becca's exhausted, so keep breakfast simple tomorrow. We'll talk when I get back." I listened once. Then I turned off my phone. Mark thought he was bringing his family home. In forty minutes, he would learn I was no longer there to take the picture.

Comments (0)

5 /5.0
VIEW ALL COMMENTS
50/500
Post Comments
Write Comment
Please enter valid text
Exceeded word limit
contents
Contents
Birthday Betrayal
Birthday Betrayal Author:Sophia Reed
Setting
Setting
Background
A A A
Font Size
A - 16 A +
Add
In
Choose Language
Language
English
English English
Tiếng Việt Vietnamese
แบบไทย Thai
Google Play Google Play
App Store App Store