Chapter 1
Words : 0
Updated : Nov 17th, 2026
In our Christmas family photo, my husband stood in the center with his arms around my best friend. Meanwhile, he shoved his phone into my hand and told me to take their picture.
"Brooke, move closer. You and Evan look so good together!"
My mother-in-law, Helen, smiled as she pulled Brooke closer to Evan.
Evan slipped an arm around her waist and lowered his head to fix her hair. He wore a warm, affectionate smile.
I stood a few feet away, holding the phone.
"What about me?"
I stared at my husband and in-laws, who had already taken their places. I could hardly believe what I was hearing.
Evan glanced at me and casually handed me his phone.
"Natalie, you take the picture."
"But I want to be in the family photo, too."
He frowned, as if my request were completely unreasonable.
"Why don't you let Brooke take your place? She's part of this family, too. You don't mind, do you?"
Brooke immediately put on an embarrassed expression.
"Come on, Natalie is his wife. It wouldn't be right for me to stand here."
"Don't be so modest."
Evan wrapped his arm around her waist. He made no effort to let her step away.
"She won't mind."
Helen laughed along.
"All right, everyone is finally together. Don't ruin the day over one picture."
I looked at them.
Nobody asked whether I wanted to step aside.
Nobody thought I deserved a place in the picture.
In the end, I raised my phone.
Everyone was in the frame, including Brooke, an outsider.
Everyone except me.
After the picture was taken, Brooke immediately posted it on social media.
[Christmas with my favorite people.]
Evan even liked her post.
I stood there, staring at the picture on my screen. Something seemed to tighten painfully in my chest.
Just a few minutes earlier, I'd thought this Christmas would be like every other year.
After all, I'd spent an entire week preparing for the gathering.
I'd started cooking the turkey and side dishes at seven that morning. I'd decorated the dining table and tidied the living room. I'd bought the Christmas tree decorations, chosen my in-laws' favorite wine, and hung the wreath beside the fireplace myself.
I'd also prepared gifts for everyone.
But when we started opening presents, Helen pushed aside the cashmere coat I'd bought her.
"This color is too old-fashioned. I like Brooke's mug much better."
The ceramic mug had cost only thirty dollars. There was even a small crack near the handle.
The coat was the same style Helen had admired at a department store last month. She'd loved it but refused to buy it because of the price.
I'd remembered every detail.
"Don't you like it?" I asked.
"It's fine. Just nothing special."
Evan picked up the mug and smiled.
"Natalie, you should learn from Brooke. She never disappoints anyone with her gifts."
I looked at him.
The custom-made leather briefcase I'd bought him was still beside his feet. He hadn't even opened its compartments before calling it too ordinary.
But the wooden Christmas reindeer Brooke gave him earned a place on the most prominent spot on the fireplace mantel.
"I like this," he told her. "I'll take it to the office tomorrow."
I suddenly didn't know how to react.
I'd spent weeks figuring out what everyone liked, yet I couldn't even get a sincere thank-you.
Brooke noticed my expression.
She opened the designer perfume I'd bought her and gasped.
"Oh my goodness! Natalie, you actually bought this?"
"You said you liked it."
"I do, but it's so expensive!"
She put the bottle down and turned toward Evan.
"You really should control her spending. She never knows when to stop or how to save money."
Before I could answer, Evan nodded.
"I agree. Natalie isn't very good at managing money sometimes."
I stared at him.
Who paid the mortgage every month?
Who covered his parents' living expenses?
Whose account paid his credit card bills?
I'd never demanded gratitude for any of it.
Yet buying Brooke perfume had somehow become another reason for her to lecture me.
And my own husband was taking her side.
At dinner, Helen started praising Brooke's job at the television station.
"Now that's a respectable career. She meets different people every day and actually has a future."
Then she turned toward me.
"Natalie, you should think about your work, too. You can't keep running those little businesses forever."
I tightened my grip on my fork.
I wanted to tell her that the business she looked down on was paying for this house and everyone sitting around the table.
But Evan answered before I could.
"Brooke definitely has more potential than Natalie. At least her job is something she can be proud of."
I looked at my husband, waiting for him to realize how insulting that sounded.
Instead, he was cutting Brooke's steak.
For a moment, I wondered if he'd ever truly considered me a wife he could be proud of.
After dinner, I didn't stay at the table.
I went into the kitchen and started clearing the dishes.
I told myself Evan probably hadn't realized how much he'd hurt me.
After all, we'd been married for years.
But as I washed the last plate, I heard his voice downstairs.
"Brooke, we should go skiing together next Christmas. Haven't you always wanted to?"
Brooke laughed happily.
"Really? You'd better keep your promise."
I turned off the faucet and didn't listen to the rest.
There was a silver gift box waiting in my bedroom drawer.
I'd planned to give it to Evan that night.
Inside was an eight-week ultrasound picture, a pair of white baby socks, and a card I'd written myself.
[Merry Christmas, Daddy.]
I was eight weeks pregnant.
My doctor said the baby was developing well.
When I first found out, I'd sat in my car for a long time, smiling. I'd imagined Evan seeing the picture, pulling me into his arms, and excitedly discussing baby names.
That's why I'd kept the news from him. I wanted to surprise him on Christmas.
I picked up the ultrasound picture and gently touched its edge.
Then I heard Brooke's voice downstairs.
"Evan, are we really not bringing Natalie with us?"
"Why would we? This trip is specifically for you."
"But she's your wife."
"Don't worry about her. She won't interfere with our plans."
I stood in the bedroom, still holding the eight-week ultrasound picture.
I'd been looking forward to sharing our baby with my husband. Meanwhile, he only wanted to spend Christmas with another woman.
I lowered my eyes to the tiny white socks inside the gift box.
The card that read [Merry Christmas, Daddy] was still lying quietly inside.
Comments (0)